Those words were said to me 11 days ago and I wasn't sure how to respond to them, so I just did the best I could with, "I'm not trying to define us."
I feel like most of the early interactions between two people who are interested in each other are tests, to an extent. How else are you going to feel each other out, determine worth and value? You want to be sure that the person is worth your time before you jump in and risk getting hurt. Still, is that really fair? Sure, we all do it, "Hmm, I wonder how he will react if I do this..." or "I wonder what she would say to that..." But is it really constructive at all? It leads to a whole lot of anxiety on both ends because you know if you're testing someone, they're probably testing you, and if they're not, you have a lot of undue stress.
Relationships are silly, intimate or otherwise. We do it as friends too, though not as much as we did it in middle school when every girl tried out three-way calling to see if their friend was a back-stabber. That's the most brutal test of them all because no matter how you answer, you're betraying someone. That's the problem with these tests, there's no easy answer. There's no way to know for sure what the other person really wants you to say. Sometimes experience is enough to at least guide you a bit, but whoever said 'honesty is the best policy' had clearly never been in a relationship.
That last sentence right there goes against everything I have stood for and anyone who reads it will probably doubt that it came from me, but bear with me. I don't for a second encourage or condone lying, especially in intimate relationships where trust has to be built and fostered, but what I've learned (despite my lack of a filter) is that sometimes you have to just feel out a situation and say what you think the other person wants you to say, provided it isn't a gross departure from what you actually believe.
This goes back to the old adage, "If you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all." But as humans in social situations, we can't always just hold our tongues entirely. Our faces tend to give us away if we're pondering something and denying that we have something to say when asked is almost as bad as saying something hurtful. Some people would be more than happy to accept your denial of opinion, but others will assume the worst. And here is where the 'anything nice to say' part comes into play.
For the purposes of this example, please assume M=Man and W=Woman, however I do not mean to insinuate that this situation only happens in heterosexual relationships or only in this direction.
W: Baby, does this dress make me look fat?
M (thinking): Oh god, this is a trick.
I know, this is the most cliche example around, but that's because it works. Now, whether the dress actually makes the woman look fat here, matters.
If it doesn't, but the man is afraid that saying "no" will seem too insincere, a good response is, "You look beautiful." Any stable woman is going to understand that as a compliment and not question it further. An unstable woman is another story altogether, but I can't help you there.
If it does make her look fat, DO NOT SAY THAT. There are much better ways to handle the situation. Again, tell her she's beautiful, that's key. Then, put the emphasis on why she's asking you about the dress. Does she feel uncomfortable in it? Does she think it makes her look fat?
W: Baby, does this dress make me look fat?
M: I think you look beautiful, as always, but what's up? Do you not like it? If you're going to be self-conscious in it, I'm sure we can find another one. I don't want you worrying about it throughout the night.
Okay, so maybe it sounds lame in writing, but it puts the emphasis on what she thinks of herself and what she'll be feeling when she wears the dress, plus it includes a compliment.
This doesn't just work in romantic relationships. I've seen one too many friends send another friend out in something atrocious because someone was afraid of hurting someone else's feelings. I'm guilty of this myself, but I've realized that you don't have to be mean to make someone realize they shouldn't be wearing what they have on. Chances are that if it's wildly inappropriate they've already second-guessed themselves. If they haven't second-guessed it, chances are that even being mean wouldn't have been enough to bring them around and then you've just pissed off your friend with nothing to show for it.
That said, how do you get back to what you really want to say?
Let's say that what you ended up saying wasn't all that far from what you really think, but it's still lacking something important that could come back to bite you later. Lying by omission. It's a sneaky little bugger. Figuring out when, if ever, you should broach the subject is very important.
There are also cases where you don't realize that what you said was off-base until later. Approaching that discrepancy may be more difficult than expected. You're likely to run into the dreaded response of, "But you said..." Okay, yes, I said it was fine; I was wrong. I changed my mind. Am I allowed to change my mind?
So do you approach the topic by first acknowledging what you said?
"Hey, remember a few weeks ago when I said...?"
Something tells me that isn't going to go over very well, especially if the other person has gotten used to your first response. If they didn't already expect you to bring this up, they're going to be completely blind-sided and likely defensive.
Two things to really think about before you begin:
1. Is it worth bringing up?
2. Why didn't you say it in the first place?
If it isn't worth bringing up, don't. There's no need to tell your friend, girlfriend, significant other that her/his attire wasn't flattering two weeks ago.
If it is worth bringing up, why didn't you say it the first time you had the chance? Was it just not the right time? Was the relationship too new? Had something already been said to make you worry about how your response would be received? These are all pretty common, it seems.
I'm almost certain it shouldn't go like this:
"Hey, remember the other day, when we were talking about the possibility of me being a rebound and how I didn't want to be a rebound? And remember how I was talking about all the things I didn't want to be and you said 'We can be whatever you want us to be' and I was really quick to say that I wasn't trying to define us? I like you, I really really do, and while I don't find it necessary to define us right now, I want to keep that possibility open in the future. I didn't realize it until your ex girlfriend starting posting on your facebook wall, but I really like spending time with you and I don't want to lose that. I guess some really lame girlie part of my is afraid that if we're undefined, you're more likely to slip away, to go back to her or someone else. I didn't mention all of this at the time because you had just finished telling me about how when you were with her she was always wanting you to change your facebook status to 'in a relationship' and how much that bugged you. I don't want you to think that's what I'm asking. I'm just asking who you are. When my friends as about you, who are you? Are you my friend? Because I don't stay up until 5am talking to just anyone and I don't kiss just anyone. I know you haven't had time to determine my worth, and I'm not asking you to drop everything (or anything!) for me, but I want to be more than friends, if you'll have me."
While I'm fairly certain that is how it shouldn't be done, I can't think of a better way to do it. Sometimes it isn't perfect and you just have to take it as it is. Sometimes, you just have to run with it.